Image source:
The Citizenry
Image source:
West Elm

The Citizenry vs West Elm

What's the difference between The Citizenry and West Elm

The Citizenry takes pride in its philosophy of creating home goods that reflect the journeys we take, partnering with master artisans from around the world and using only local materials. They sell directly to customers online, eliminating middlemen and offering handmade goods at reasonable prices. Their products are crafted with a soul and a story, blending modern style with timeworn techniques. West Elm, on the other hand, focuses on using design to do better for the earth, communities, and customers. They support sustainability initiatives and ethical production practices. Their in-house team designs exclusive collections, championing the maker movement and investing in small American-made businesses. They also collaborate with artisan collectives worldwide to preserve handcraft traditions and create sustainable employment opportunities. In terms of certifications, The Citizenry offers GOTS Certified, OEKO-TEX® Standard 100, FSC Certified, and SVLK Timber Legality Verification for some products. West Elm has a wider range of certifications including GOTS Certified, FSC Certified, OCS Certified, OEKO-TEX® Standard 100, Global Recycled Standard, Recycled Claims Standard Greenguard Gold Certified. Additionally, The Citizenry participates in the World Fair Trade Organization Guarantee while West Elm has certifications such as Fair Trade USA Certified and Nest's Ethical Handcraft Program. The Citizenry claims benefits such as handcrafted products assembled in the USA with water-based finishes. West Elm does not make any unverified sustainable benefit claims. Overall,the key differences between The Citizenry and West Elm lie in their sourcing practices (partnering with local artisans vs supporting American-made businesses), product certifications offered (GOTS vs a wider range), participation in fair trade organizations (World Fair Trade Organization Guarantee vs Fair Trade USA), as well as specific unverified sustainable benefits claimed by The Citizenry.

CB2 has this but West Elm does not have it

CB2 has this but West Elm does not have it

CB2 has this but West Elm does not have it

CB2 has this but West Elm does not have it

- The Citizenry focuses on partnering with master artisans from around the world and selling their handmade goods directly to customers online, eliminating middlemen and offering reasonable prices. - The Citizenry emphasizes creating home goods with a soul, a story, and a purpose by blending modern style with timeworn techniques from different countries. - The Citizenry offers small batch creations that are handcrafted, hand numbered, and available in limited quantities to ensure uniqueness. - The Citizenry is committed to fair trade standards, providing fair wages to their artisan partners and supporting their crafts and businesses through sustaining grants. - West Elm supports sustainability initiatives through 60% of product sales, champions ethical production and worker well-being, collaborates with artisan collectives worldwide, and invests in local economies.

Company Description

The Citizenry
The Citizenry is a Dallas-based retailer founded in 2014 that specializes in ethically crafted and sustainably sourced home goods. With a focus on celebrating the people behind their products, they travel the world to partner with master artisans, blending modern style with time-tested techniques. By eliminating middlemen and selling directly to customers online, The Citizenry offers handmade goods at more reasonable prices than traditional luxury boutiques. They prioritize fair trade standards, paying artisans fairly for their skills, and are committed to sustainability with organic materials, non-toxic certifications, responsible forestry methods, and ethical sourcing of wool and leather.
West Elm
West Elm is a home furnishings retailer that uses design to help the environment, communities, and customers. The company's products are 95% designed in-house, and 60% of sales support sustainability initiatives. West Elm is a leader in sustainability, supporting small American-made businesses and collaborating with artisan collectives around the world. Certified organic cotton bedding and bath towels are sustainably sourced, and wood furniture is sustainably sourced. Certified nontoxic furniture has been screened for over 100,000 chemicals and VOCs. Founded in 2002, West Elm is headquartered in Brooklyn, NY.

Differences at a Glance

The Citizenry

West Elm

Headquarters

Year Founded

Store Type

Product Type

Aesthetic

Parent Company

Welcome Discount

Price

Quality Level

Reviews on Website

Free Returns

White Glove Delivery

Product Warranty

Registry Available

Made-to-Order Items

Free Swatches

Designer Collaborations

In-House Design Services

Trade Program

Trade Discount

Dallas, Texas

2014

Online, Showroom

Furniture, Furnishings

Global Modern

None

None

$$$$

Mid-High

Yes

No

White Glove Delivery

Not Specified

No

Yes

Available for a Fee

Not Available

Yes

10%

Brooklyn, New York

2002

Online, Showroom

Furniture, Furnishings

Mid-Century Modern

Williams-Sonoma, Inc.

15%

$$

Mid

No

Yes

White Glove Delivery

Not Specified

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Free

Yes

20%

Sustainability Mission Comparison

The Citizenry participates in the World Fair Trade Organization Guarantee, while West Elm has certifications such as Fair Trade USA Certified, Better Cotton Initiative, Craftmark, HERproject, and Nest's Ethical Handcraft Program.
Image source:
The Citizenry
Image source:
West Elm

Sustainable Product Certifications and Programs

The Citizenry

West Elm

Sustainable Forestry Initiative

Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certification Warranty

Appalachian Hardwood Manufacturers Inc.

National Hardwood Lumber Association

Yes

Yes

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

Yes

White Glove Delivery

Not Specified

No

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

White Glove Delivery

Not Specified

Yes

Yes

Sustainable and Equitable Labor Programs

Sustainability Mission

The Citizenry
The Citizenry is a retailer that prioritizes people and the planet, offering home goods with soul and a story. They celebrate the individuals behind their products, fostering connections across cultures and continents. Their designs combine ethical craftsmanship with elevated design, guaranteeing fair trade processes and paying double the wage requirement. Partnering with master artisans, they create exclusive collections using all-natural materials and age-old craft techniques that have low carbon emissions and zero waste. The Citizenry is committed to sustainability, sourcing organic cotton, ensuring nontoxic bedding, responsibly sourcing wood products, and ethically sourcing wool and leather materials.
West Elm
West Elm is committed to sustainability and reducing its environmental impact. The company sources organic and sustainably sourced materials, such as FSC-certified wood, recycled polyester, and organic cotton. Its products are certified nontoxic and free from harmful chemicals. West Elm also uses handcrafted and local materials, as well as contract grade, low-VOC, reclaimed, recycled, upcycled, water-based finishes, and water efficient materials. By doing so, the company has saved 2.3 billion liters of water in 2019 and kept 66 million plastic bottles out of landfills in 2020.

Sustainable Product Certifications

The Citizenry offers several product certifications, including GOTS Certified, OEKO-TEX® Standard 100, FSC Certified, and SVLK Timber Legality Verification. These certifications ensure that some of their products meet specific environmental and ethical standards. On the other hand, West Elm also has a range of certifications for some of their products. They are GOTS Certified, FSC Certified, OCS Certified, OEKO-TEX® Standard 100, Global Recycled Standard, Recycled Claims Standard, Greenguard Gold Certified, and REACH compliant. These certifications demonstrate West Elm's commitment to sustainability and safety in their product offerings. It is important to note that while both retailers have certifications for certain products in their collections, the retailers themselves are not certified.

The Citizenry

West Elm

FSC Certified

GOTS Certified

OCS Certified

OEKO-TEX® Standard 100

EcoTex

Global Recycled Standard

Recycled Claims Standard

Greenguard Gold Certified

SCS Indoor Advantage Gold

REACH

Ecolable

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

No

Sustainable and Equitable Labor Programs

The Citizenry participates in the World Fair Trade Organization Guarantee, while West Elm has certifications such as Fair Trade USA Certified, Better Cotton Initiative, Craftmark, HERproject, and Nest's Ethical Handcraft Program.

The Citizenry

West Elm

Goodweave

Fair Trade USA

Better Cotton Initiative

Craftmark

HERproject

Nest Ethical Handcraft Program

Fifteen Percent Pledge

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Contributor

Christi Farrell

Christi is a licensed architect and interior designer specializing in sustainability. She enjoys teaching design and bringing transparency to the impact that furniture has on our planet.

Subscribe to our newsletter for updates!

More from Studio Marlowe