Image source:
West Elm
Image source:
Poly and Bark

West Elm vs Poly and Bark

What's the difference between West Elm and Poly and Bark

West Elm and Poly and Bark are two furniture retailers with distinct differences in their approach to sustainability and ethical labor practices. West Elm places a strong emphasis on sustainability, with 60% of their product sales supporting at least one of their sustainability initiatives. They also champion the maker movement, collaborate with artisan collectives around the world, and were the first-ever home retailer to join Fair Trade USA. In contrast, Poly and Bark does not have any certifications for their products or participate in equitable labor programs. West Elm offers a range of product certifications for some of their products, including GOTS Certified, FSC Certified, OCS Certified, OEKO-TEX® Standard 100, Global Recycled Standard, Recycled Claims Standard, Greenguard Gold Certified and REACH. On the other hand, Poly and Bark does not offer any certified products at this time. In terms of equitable labor programs, West Elm participates in several programs such as Fair Trade USA Certified and Nest's Ethical Handcraft Program to ensure that workers receive fair wages and safe working conditions. In contrast, Poly and Bark does not participate in any equitable labor programs. Lastly, West Elm claims several sustainable benefits such as handcrafted products assembled in the USA with low-VOC finishes while using reclaimed or recycled materials. On the other hand,Poly and Bark does not make any claims to unverified sustainable benefits. Overall it is clear that West Elm has a stronger commitment to sustainability initiatives while also ensuring ethical labor practices compared to Poly & Bark who do not have these measures in place yet.

CB2 has this but West Elm does not have it

CB2 has this but West Elm does not have it

CB2 has this but West Elm does not have it

CB2 has this but West Elm does not have it

- West Elm offers several product certifications, including GOTS Certified and FSC Certified products, whereas Poly and Bark does not have any certified products. - West Elm participates in equitable labor programs such as Fair Trade USA Certified and Nest's Ethical Handcraft Program, while Poly and Bark does not participate in any equitable labor programs. - West Elm makes several claims to sustainable benefits such as low-VOC, nontoxic, reclaimed, recycled, upcycled products with water-based finishes and water-efficient production. On the other hand, Poly and Bark does not make any claims to unverified sustainable benefits. - 95% of West Elm's products are designed in-house by their exclusive team in Brooklyn. In contrast, Poly and Bark carefully constructs updated takes on iconic furniture from a long-standing tradition of expert craftsmen inspired by a melting pot of cultures. - West Elm collaborates with various organizations such as BSR|HERproject™, The Trevor Project®, Jackie Robinson Foundation among others. However, Poly & Bark has not made claims regarding collaborations with other organizations or causes.

Company Description

West Elm
West Elm is a home furnishings retailer that uses design to help the environment, communities, and customers. The company's products are 95% designed in-house, and 60% of sales support sustainability initiatives. West Elm is a leader in sustainability, supporting small American-made businesses and collaborating with artisan collectives around the world. Certified organic cotton bedding and bath towels are sustainably sourced, and wood furniture is sustainably sourced. Certified nontoxic furniture has been screened for over 100,000 chemicals and VOCs. Founded in 2002, West Elm is headquartered in Brooklyn, NY.
Poly and Bark
Poly & Bark is an online furniture retailer that provides quality, affordable pieces to make home a haven. Their collections are globally inspired, featuring updated takes on iconic furniture and much-loved classics. Careful attention is paid to every detail from design to construction to ensure the highest quality product. By being an online company, they can pass on the savings of not having a brick and mortar showroom or middle man markups on to the customer - pricing up to 50% less than traditional retailers. Founded in 2016, their mission is to make stylish furniture available for everyone in Chicago, Illinois and beyond.

Differences at a Glance

West Elm

Poly and Bark

Headquarters

Year Founded

Store Type

Product Type

Aesthetic

Parent Company

Welcome Discount

Price

Quality Level

Reviews on Website

Free Returns

White Glove Delivery

Product Warranty

Registry Available

Made-to-Order Items

Free Swatches

Designer Collaborations

In-House Design Services

Trade Program

Trade Discount

Brooklyn, New York

2002

Online, Showroom

Furniture, Furnishings

Mid-Century Modern

Williams-Sonoma, Inc.

15%

$$

Mid

No

Yes

White Glove Delivery

Not Specified

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Free

Yes

20%

Chicago, Illinois

2016

Online

Furniture, Furnishings

Mid-Century Modern, Scandinavian Modern

None

$25 Off First Order Of $100+

$$

Mid

Yes

One Item Free Of Charge Per Category

White Glove Delivery

Yes

No

No

Yes

No

Not Available

Yes

5% on orders $5,000+

Sustainability Mission Comparison

West Elm participates in a variety of equitable labor programs, such as Fair Trade USA Certified, Better Cotton Initiative, Craftmark, HERproject and Nest's Ethical Handcraft Program. These programs are designed to ensure that workers receive fair wages and safe working conditions. On the other hand, Poly and Bark does not participate in any equitable labor programs. This means that the company does not have any measures in place to ensure that its workers are treated fairly or given safe working conditions. While West Elm is committed to providing its workers with fair wages and safe working conditions through its equitable labor programs, Poly and Bark has yet to take any steps towards this goal.
Image source:
West Elm
Image source:
Poly and Bark

Sustainable Product Certifications and Programs

West Elm

Poly and Bark

Sustainable Forestry Initiative

Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certification Warranty

Appalachian Hardwood Manufacturers Inc.

National Hardwood Lumber Association

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

White Glove Delivery

Not Specified

Yes

Yes

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

White Glove Delivery

Yes

No

No

Sustainable and Equitable Labor Programs

Sustainability Mission

West Elm
West Elm is committed to sustainability and reducing its environmental impact. The company sources organic and sustainably sourced materials, such as FSC-certified wood, recycled polyester, and organic cotton. Its products are certified nontoxic and free from harmful chemicals. West Elm also uses handcrafted and local materials, as well as contract grade, low-VOC, reclaimed, recycled, upcycled, water-based finishes, and water efficient materials. By doing so, the company has saved 2.3 billion liters of water in 2019 and kept 66 million plastic bottles out of landfills in 2020.
Poly and Bark
Poly and Bark is a retailer that specializes in modern furniture designs. While the company has not specified a sustainability mission, they have made sustainability claims such as using materials sourced from renewable forests and minimizing their carbon footprint while shipping. Poly and Bark is committed to providing customers with quality furniture that is produced in an environmentally-friendly manner, helping to promote sustainable practices within the industry.

Sustainable Product Certifications

West Elm offers a range of product certifications, including GOTS Certified, FSC Certified, OCS Certified, OEKO-TEX® Standard 100, Global Recycled Standard, Recycled Claims Standard, Greenguard Gold Certified and REACH. On the other hand, Poly and Bark does not have any certifications for their products. It is important to note that while West Elm has several certifications available for some of their products, not all of their products are certified. However, Poly and Bark does not offer any certified products at this time.

West Elm

Poly and Bark

FSC Certified

GOTS Certified

OCS Certified

OEKO-TEX® Standard 100

EcoTex

Global Recycled Standard

Recycled Claims Standard

Greenguard Gold Certified

SCS Indoor Advantage Gold

REACH

Ecolable

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

Sustainable and Equitable Labor Programs

West Elm participates in a variety of equitable labor programs, such as Fair Trade USA Certified, Better Cotton Initiative, Craftmark, HERproject and Nest's Ethical Handcraft Program. These programs are designed to ensure that workers receive fair wages and safe working conditions. On the other hand, Poly and Bark does not participate in any equitable labor programs. This means that the company does not have any measures in place to ensure that its workers are treated fairly or given safe working conditions. While West Elm is committed to providing its workers with fair wages and safe working conditions through its equitable labor programs, Poly and Bark has yet to take any steps towards this goal.

West Elm

Poly and Bark

Goodweave

Fair Trade USA

Better Cotton Initiative

Craftmark

HERproject

Nest Ethical Handcraft Program

Fifteen Percent Pledge

No

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

Contributor

Christi Farrell

Christi is a licensed architect and interior designer specializing in sustainability. She enjoys teaching design and bringing transparency to the impact that furniture has on our planet.

Subscribe to our newsletter for updates!

More from Studio Marlowe